Skip Navigation

Go
Species Search:
{pagetitle}

The latest in news, stories and just plain fun from the world of eNature.com.

Recent Entries

Monthly Archives

The Monarch Butterflies You See Migrating Now Aren’t The Ones You Saw Last Spring
Posted on Friday, September 07, 2012 by eNature
Monarch Butterfly
Monarch Butterfly
© Derek Ramsey, CCL
Common Milkweed
Common Milkweed
© Kevin Adams

Fall’s in the air throughout most of North America. 

You’ve probably noticed that your local birds are preparing for it— and so are our many of our butterflies.

Monarch butterflies are famous for their annual migrations. Some of these insects travel thousands of miles each fall—an astonishing distance for such fragile creatures.

Yet few people realize that the Monarchs we see in the spring are not necessarily the same ones that fluttered past in the fall.

Beginning in late September, the skies along the Gulf Coast of Texas slowly become filled with meandering groups of Monarchs. Their flight, while not hurried, is purposeful, moving southwest toward a small forest in the highlands of Central Mexico. These butterflies travel from southern Canada and the northern United States at a rate of approximately 50 miles per day. They’ll spend the winter in a few small groves of evergreen trees, with each grove containing as many as 20 million butterflies. Sheltered from the wind and snow, the butterflies conserve energy, for they still have a lot of work ahead of them.

The Monarchs become active again in February. Mating begins, and the air fills with swirling masses of copulating pairs. The first warm days of late March trigger their northward flight. A close look at these butterflies, now eight months old, reveals that their wings are faded and tattered. Still, the Monarchs fan out across the southern United States, looking for Milkweed plants on which to deposit their eggs.

Four days later, the eggs hatch, producing small caterpillars that immediately begin to feed on the Milkweed leaves. Ten to fifteen days later, each caterpillar stops feeding and forms its chrysalis—a beautiful soft green jewel flecked with gold. In another ten to fifteen days the chrysalis splits open, and a new Monarch emerges.

This generation of butterflies mates, lays eggs, and dies within the span of a few weeks. During this time it moves north, following the progress of spring and the emergence of Milkweed.

By the end of summer, two more of these short-lived generations will have repeated the process, ultimately coming to inhabit the Milkweed patches in the far north latitudes.

Thus the Monarchs born in the Northeast and Canada in September are the great great grandchildren of the last Monarchs to inhabit the area. These are the ones that will head to Mexico. They’re significantly larger than the three generations that preceded them and still sexually immature. Rather than mate and lay eggs, they seek out nectar-producing flowers. The nectar serves two purposes: some of it fuels the southward migration, and some of it is converted to fat reserves that sustain the butterflies through the winter.

This incredible annual cycle applies to all Monarchs east of the Rockies. The populations in the West follow a similar pattern, though their migratory path is westward, from the Great Basin to overwintering sites along the Pacific Coast.

Since 1992 MonarchWatch has been carefully tracking Monarch Butterflies as they migrate.  Much of their data comes from the work of volunteers who tag and track the butterflies. They can always use more helpers…..

Are you seeing butterflies in your neighborhood?

Permalink

Comments

Today is September 8, 2012.  I live in Glen Head, NY, and today I have Monarch, Painted Lady, and Cabbage butterflies as well as two different kinds of Flickers—one with a dull grey underwing and some orange and brown on the top wings, and one type that is a bit more yellowish.  I also have an unknown butterfly.  It is a bit smaller than the Painted ladies.  It is mostly brown and orange and it has a large white splotch (not a circle) on its underwing.  Last week I had Yellow Swallowtails and Spicebush Swallowtails in the garden.

Posted by Ingrid Feingold on 9/8

I live in Milwaukee, WI. When I was a kid, I used to see the Monarch as well as many other colorful butterfly’s all spring and summer.  Now, I rarely see any at all.  How sad.

Posted by Chay Roberts on 9/8

I live on the E Central Coast of Florida.  We have had a banner butterfly summer!  The Dutchman’s pipevine has had several generations of polydamus swallowtails, the zebra longwings have been plentiful after a two-year absence, lots of Gulf fritillaries, monarchs, yellow sulfurs, and one or two giant swallowtails.  Earlier in the spring we “midwifed” 10 black swallowtail cats who were being decimated by the boat-tailed grackles.  Only two pupae hatched out, however.

Posted by Jean Katsaros on 9/8

Today is September 8, 2012.  We live in Wakefield, RI.  Two days ago, three monarch caterpillars took up position on our front porch.  One of them made its chrysalis two days ago, the other two were yesterday.  I am keeping my Facebook fans up to date with daily pictures!
I have shown the neighbours’ children and our son and made reference to Eric Carle’s The Very Hungry Caterpillar to help them understand.
Most people never get to see this and we have three of them on our front porch.  I have let the milkweed grow in our front bed on purpose to attract the monarchs!

Posted by Sarah Denis on 9/8

It is now September 8, 2012, and I have lots of different butterflies still coming to my property in Palm Beach County, Florida.  I have Monarchs year round, and have milkweed everywhere just to satisfy them.  Last year I watched my first ever Monarch emerge, and I am 58 years old and raised in Maryland on a farm!  I have Dutchman’s Pipevine that I grew from cuttings and I’ve been watching the Polydamous all summer.  I have many Zebras and Sulfurs and the Monarch look-alikes, the Queens and Viceroys. The Gulf Frittilaries are new to me and so beautiful! Plant the right plants and they will come!

Posted by Lucinda Foster on 9/8

Red Creek NY ~ not great at naming the butterflies yet, but we have planted a butterfly bush that is covered with mostly Monarchs (I believe) some are much smaller than others.  We are also getting hummingbird moths ~ so pretty.  If you can plant one of these bushes and love butterflies ...  you wont be disappointed!

Posted by Julie vicinus on 9/8

I live in the western US, close to the San Francisco peninsula. Our California monarchs won’t arrive in major numbers for a few more weeks. They winter in a eucalyptus grove in Pacific Grove, near Monterey, CA. They are amazing to see with their wings folded and sleeping along the leaves, almost on top of one another.

Posted by Patricia Nipper on 9/8

I am still a bit confused about the generations. I am in northern Vermont. I have been raising Monarch cats since mid-July. Are all the butterflies I released generation 4 or did they lay eggs and create generation 4?  It just seems that the Monarchs I released in August stayed and layed eggs and perhaps even those larvae grew and laid eggs. Only now in September do I notice only instar 5 cats on the milkweed, no tiny cats,  and when I release butterflies, they disappear, unlike the August ones who stayed.  Am I confused and not understanding something?

Also, what happens to the Monarchs who eclose too late for the migration? Do they just go south on their own?

Posted by Andree on 9/8

Posting again because I failed to activate notifications Sorry!

Posted by Andree on 9/8

Here is Central New York (Syracuse) you see Monarchs every time you go outside…more than in earlier summer.  so the migration continues as of 09/09/12.

Posted by David Martin on 9/9

I love hearing about all the butterfly activity from coast to coast!!  So true, get the right plants, hope for fair weather, and sit back and enjoy the “flying flowers!”  I have learned from observation just how territorial these fragile-looking creatures are.  They spend an awful lot of time chasing out intruders.  Forgot to mention—for FL folks and maybe others in warmer climates…fennel!  Once you get it started, it lasts for years and overwinters in the open!  I have a plant that must be going on 4 years old.  For Patricia near San Fran, I’ve visited out your way and you are L-U-C-K-Y!  Heaven!!

Posted by Jean Katsaros on 9/9

We live on Long Island, NY and planted swamp milkweed this year. New to “butterfly watching” we have truly been rewarded. Last week I noticed that the common milkweed plants (still in cellpacks that I was intending to transplant) were leafless! And lo and behold, there were 3 small Monarch ceterpillars searching for more. I moved each to their own swamp milkweed pants and within a few moments they began to feast. I kept track of them for 3 days but can no longer find the 2 largest. I assume the chrysalis is well camoflauged. The third is not large yet. I even witnessed a Monarch laying single eggs on many leaves of the swamp milkweed. Amazing!

Posted by Paula Mancuso on 9/9

I’m in Milwaukee, Wi.  This has been a strange year for butterflies.  I have a huge butterfly friendly garden because, as a teacher, I have gathered eggs, raised and released Monarchs and Swallowtails for over 20 years.  We had tons of Painted Ladies and Angel-winged butterflies this spring, and Monarchs early on. They were all pretty much gone by mid July.  Also, I’ve seen only a few Swallowtails all summer.  I’m wondering if the heat and drought wiped them out.  So glad to hear that they are around in other parts of the country, and I’m hopeful for next year.

Posted by Marilynn Weiland on 9/9

I live in Northeast Pa and we are seeing 2-3 monach a day in our travels locally. We have several butterfly weed and bush plants and did not have as many visiting this year as last.
I will never forget the year 2006. For some reason our plants and bushes were covered with larva from monarchs, a sight to see. Same year, our parsley was enjoyed by many black swallowtail larva. Any reason for this to occur? Never happened again so far..

Posted by Bea Ellis on 9/10

9/10 2012 New Durham, NH I Have had MANY monarchs feeding in my gardens this past week.  They have spent a lot of time on JoePye weed.  I got an excellent pic of 8 on one flowerhead.  I saw no territoriality issues.

Posted by LES TURNER on 9/10

To Les Turner:  I have seen only territoriality between b’fly species thus far.  But I’ve also seen b’flies chase, and be chased by, large wasps.  I know many wasps are mortal enemies of the cats and b’flies and maybe even the eggs. 

To Bea Ellis:  I don’t understand the ebb and flow of b’fly populations, either.  I’ve been told simply that “it happens!”  I need to do more research, but that would necessitate me NOT watching them!  grin

Posted by Jean Katsaros on 9/10

I have been seeing the migrating Monarchs along the Mid coast of Maine for about 2 weeks now.

Posted by Cody on 9/11

September 11, 2012
Smith Point Park County Beach on Long Island,
Hundreds upon hundreds of monarchs migrating!!
North Wind and all of the monarchs are heading west along the shoreline and dunes.
What a sight.

Posted by Tim Green on 9/11

I second what Chay said. I live in Milwaukee, WI and the Monarchs used to be quite common. Sadly, now the sight of them is much less common and I certainly miss being able to watch them fly from flower to flower. Maybe I’ll try planting some milkweed? smile

Posted by Jen on 9/11

The monarchs arrived in my garden here in San Diego about 10 days ago.  They’re still around (saw one this morning) but no doubt they’re not the same ones that first showed up.  Really loving having them around. And I’ve made a point of planting native plants and not using any kind of chemicals on my garden for the last 10 years which I hope helps all the butterflies and all the other critters that show up here.

Posted by mark patterson on 9/11

Hello, Today is Sept. 10. I help in our school garden. Over the summer I planted 3 milkweed plants to attract Monarchs.  What a thrill when I spotted 2 butterflies there within the week. But, even more of a thrill—on Sept. 10—-I counted 6 Monarch caterpillars on those same plants! Hope the students can watch the process and bid adios to the newbies when they emerge!

Posted by Emmie Karam on 9/11

I remember back in the late 70’s I’d see them literally cover the Eucalyptus trees in Don Castro Park in Hayward, Ca. What an awesome site! There were literally thousands of them….too numerous to count. I hope they are still there….it would be about this time of year, too!

Posted by La Dawn on 9/11

I see Monarch butterflies all of the time!  Along with the Yellow Swallow butterflies and the Painted Ladies.  I have several types of flowers in my flower beds every year including milkweed. I also have several types of bees, wasp, squirrels, rabbits, birds, hummingbird moths & hummingbirds and all kinds of other cute little creatures (Smile).  I live in Sioux Falls, SD.

Posted by Barb on 9/11

Very Excited this year, I have native milkweed in my front and milkweed in my back flower beds. The one in the back(nonnative) is covered with Monarch caterpillars. This is the first year in the 2 1/2 yrs I have had this planted that I’ve had these visitors. I also have gulf fritillarys on the passionflower. I have many new visitors this year bees, bluebirds, lady bugs and lots of anoles, frogs and dragonflies. So happy because this is what I’ve worked for in the 2 1/2 yrs I have lived here in the coastal Florida panhandle.

Posted by Dena on 9/11

I live in Dallas, TX. I have not seen any monarchs yet. I am worried because Dallas has been a bit obsessive with the West Nile mosquito spraying. They spray by plane at night. I can’t help but wonder if they’ve considered how this will impact the monarch migration.

Posted by Anastasia on 9/11

The monarch I saw yesterday afternoon on my butterfly bush is the first I’ve seen since in 2012.  I live in Deming, NM (in the southwest portion of New Mexico).

Posted by Ruth on 9/11

Talk about synchronicity! Tonight, harried, I was scurrying off to the gas station across the street when I stopped dead in my tracks. A glorious orange and golden, black lined monarch was flitting about a plant. A purplish plant, I wasn’t aware of its name, I only knew that this was unusual. I had noticed maybe 3 or 4 of these monarchs in recent days, maybe 2-3 weeks at max.

I stopped and really studied the beauty of this mangificent insect. It looks like art deco on wings.

When I got in, I couldn’t believe the news: NBC was running a segment on a Massachusetts butterfly assocation that is tracking migratory patterns of butterflies and how, with climate change, they are shifting.

Then, I saw your story in my Inbox.

I have long thought that climate change is being reflected in nature all around us. I have seen different sorts of birds every year. The sounds also change as the birds have different sounds.

Posted by Laurie Wiegler on 9/11

Loved the article—-will keep this info in mind plant lots of milkweed and hope we get some Monarchs heading North in the Spring. This has been a banner year for butterflies here in Central Fl. We have Zebra longwings and Gulf F.,Swallowtails, White Peacock,and Sulfur.

Posted by jan spotts on 9/12

4 Corners area, NM.  Monarchs arrived on Sept. 7.  And sparrows got here about the same time.  It is so nice being on a flight path…..all the wonderful creatures that stop in to say hello.

Posted by rae linden on 9/12

9/12/12 I’m in LI, Rocky Pt. Today lots more Monarchs, a slew of Painted Ladies, a baby Black Swallowtail & several other BF species. Since moving here 4 years ago I’ve increased my BF/hummingbird perennials to 11 BF Bushes, several Swamp Milkweed & Butterfly Weed plants, Agastache, Salvia, Caryopteris & maybe 80 more perennials & each year the # of visitors grow, incl. 2 steady female Hummers! I have Monarch & Black Swallowtail cats on the dill & parsley. Captured on film my first Clearwing Hummingbird moth last week but they have been around since last summer. I have been able to get some butterflies on my hand which is a thrill! Once the Hummers get used to you, they don’t take off when you go outside. I wish to continue helping their population grow! Oct. 2011 there were a dozen or so Black Swallowtail cats still feeding on dill so I brought them in until they made cocoons, then brought back outside in a butterfly house where most of them hatched in the spring. THAT was awesome!

Posted by Andrea on 9/12

Thank you for explaining the life cycles of the Monarch trough out the year.  Most people who visit our butterfly house have no idea that the Monarchs you see throw summer have never been to Mexico!  Here in Illinois, it has been so hot all summer, if we get rain it comes in a high winds and heavy quick down pours so it washes away.  I have seen a big difference in our Monarchs, if the young caterpillar made it through heat,predictors, they were washed away in storms.  We went two months before I saw a single Monarch.  We had some rain,not enough, and cooler temps for some days.  We did see 4 Monarchs during about a 3 week span.  Now for the last 3 weeks there have been none.  I hope this last cycle of Monarchs fair better in other states to make the trip to Mexico.  Heard reports that some of the Monarchs that would have been in our area pushed north farther into Canada than ever before in larger numbers.  Unfortunately the milkweed is sparse or not at all in some of those areas.

Posted by Kim Sheahan on 9/13

I live in Western Mass. and am thrilled at the number of monarchs visiting my butterfly bushes this year.  They are here daily usually 5-6 at a time on each bush.  This is the 1st year they have been here in abundance.  While there is no milkweed in my yard, I do know there is some nearby and am wondering if/when it would be possible to check for eggs laid in this area, if at all.

Posted by Brenda Galway on 9/13

  I am the Naturalist in a local State Park near Durham, North Carolina, and have monitored Monarchs now for two years. Sadly we have found some eggs but no evidence of monarchs. Our milkweed plants do well yet we have not seen Monarchs in our Park. Twenty miles east of us there is a site with lots of eggs, instars, and yes Monarchs.  We have visited that site and catalogued those Monarchs reporting data to MLMP.

Posted by HERB ENGLISHMAN on 9/13

That is sad Herb. From what we’re seeing, the Monarchs now prefer the northern climes ...were you seeing them in the Carolinas 5-10 yrs ago? When did you notice the change?

Posted by Laurie Wiegler on 9/13

Kim from IL. One of the frustrating things this year was watching clouds come toward norther IL and pass us to dump rain as it traveled to the east coast.  Looks like the eastern coast monarchs are fairing pretty well, as I had commented we had heard that many had pushed north of the US into Canada.  Some of them may now be following the sea board as they move down.

Posted by Kim Sheahan on 9/13

Andree, there are 4 to 5 generations in a year. So let’s start with the last generation the fall generation.  Cooler nights help alter the eggs in the fall, this generation will live 5 to 6 months.  This is the generation that Migrates, not necessarily to Mexico because west of the Rockies usually go to California, east of the Rockies go to Mexico except for some along the east coast which go to Florida, not all travel to Mexico.  A monarch usually starts to mate from 3 to 4 days were the fall batch usually are mating at 3 to 4 months.  The Mexico Monarch stays until the end of February beginning of March, migration starts all the Monarchs take off moving into the lower states.  Here they lay their eggs and die.  The eggs grow to butterfly 1st generation, 1st generation lay eggs which grow to 2nd generation, 2nd generation eggs grow to become 3rd generation, back to fall, only fall Monarchs live for 5 to 6 months and migrate.  Monarchs from the north never return north from Mexico.

Posted by Kim Sheahan on 9/13

Thank you, Kim. That much I can understand. But the Monarchs that do arrive in the north here: do they lay eggs, which grow up and lay eggs, which grow up to the fourth generation that goes to Mexico? They are here from July on, and it seems like too much time for them to just lay the fall migrating generation. I see all stages of caterpillars all summer, and that is what confuses me. Maybe I can describe it as generation 3.5?

Posted by Andree Sanborn on 9/13

Yes in the north we have 3 to 4 generations usually. We see the first Monarchs in mid to late June or early July.  They are usually duller in color, signaling there age and journey when they arrive generally from farther south.  They are our start.  They lay eggs and in 4 weeks the caterpillars are mature, go to pupae and emerge. Adults are alive 2 to 4 weeks tops and then their eggs mature.  Our last batch usually is laid in late August beginning of September.  My last batch just emerged. Often this is a 5th generation for us. Temperature plays a large part in this life cycle.    (The Mexico monarch would have been last year’s 5 generation. It crosses into Texas lays and dies.  It offspring travel into Arkansas and Missouri 1st generation.  It lays eggs and its offspring travel into IL and Wi 2nd generation.  We would then have the second arriving, the 3rd and 4th staying here and the 5th leaving or the Mexico Monarch.)

Posted by Kim Sheahan on 9/13

We have been up in Bridgton, ME the past few weeks and have seen an amazing number of migrating Monarchs. They seem to be everywhere. We especially enjoyed seeing them from our kayaks while they were flying over the water.

Posted by Jan Jukkola on 9/16

I’m in Chester VA. I had planted Fennel, Rue, Parsley and Angelica for host with Zinnias for nectar. I had so many Eastern Black Swallowtails cats I eventually had to buy parsley and dill to feed them. I witnessed the process of the forming of the chrysalis. What an amazing event. This morning, I awoke to a female Eastern Black hanging on to a sea shell on my kitchen counter! I had found the chrysalis on the ground in the flower bed attached to a leaf. I had set it in the sea shell to watch. Too bad I missed it emerging - haven’t witnessed that yet.  Ive only spotted one Monarch in my flowers so far. I do hope that won’t be all! Next year I will have Milkweed planted for them.

Posted by Karen Daniel on 9/16

I am spending the week on the beach in rhode island and we have thousands of monarchs flying around the house, dunes and shrubs!! amazing!

Posted by susan on 9/19

I’ve been fascinated by and have loved butterflies all my life! I live in Michigan and there are far less varieties of them than there used to be.  Some types I have not seen in over a decade, and believe me, I am always looking!  This year, however, I have seen at least a dozen types—mostly around my lovely butterfly bush and my asters. 

However, I planted three young milkweeds last year that I got by the roadside.  They didn’t bloom last year, came back this year and grew HUGE, but still never bloomed.  Does anyone know why?  I was hoping to attract the monarchs that fly through and entice them to stick around.
I heard that either the male or female don’t bloom.  Is this true, or is there a type that doesn’t bloom?  I’d appreciate any input.

Posted by Barbara on 9/20

I live in north central Oklahoma. I have been counting the monarchs for several years now. Last year at this time I often saw several dozen a day. This year the count is only a tiny fraction of that number.

I believe it’s a result of a combination of factors. First and foremost their milkweed is getting destroyed deliberately in many parts of the country, sadly including Oklahoma. It’s regarded as a “pest” plant and eradicated wherever it grows. Second, this year was a year of unprecedented drought over more than a third of the US, unseasonable rains in another portion of the country, and drastic record-breaking fires—again, sadly, including Oklahoma. Between the drought and the wildfires at least one generation of the butterflies would have been disrupted, even destroyed in many places…add in the loss of their critical plant and the results are predictable.

Posted by Maire on 9/22
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Advanced Search
Subscribe to newsletters

 

 

© 2008 eNature.com